What Is a Hiatal Hernia, and Can It Cause Persistent Acid Reflux?

You have been managing acid reflux with dietary changes or medication, but the burning sensation or sour taste in your mouth keeps returning. While gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is a common cause of persistent reflux, an underlying hiatal hernia may also contribute to ongoing symptoms in some people.

A hiatal hernia occurs when part of the stomach moves through the diaphragm into the chest cavity. Not everyone with a hiatal hernia develops acid reflux, but the condition can weaken the body’s natural barrier against stomach acid flowing back into the oesophagus. Understanding this relationship can help you recognise when persistent symptoms may warrant further medical assessment.

What is a hiatal hernia?

A hiatal hernia develops when the upper part of the stomach pushes through an opening in the diaphragm called the hiatus. Normally, the oesophagus passes through this opening before connecting to the stomach. If the opening becomes enlarged or the surrounding tissues weaken, part of the stomach may move upwards into the chest.

There are two main types of hiatal hernias:

Sliding hiatal hernia

This is the most common type. The junction between the oesophagus and stomach, together with part of the stomach, slides above the diaphragm. Many people with a small sliding hiatal hernia have no symptoms.

Paraoesophageal hiatal hernia

This less common type occurs when part of the stomach pushes through the diaphragm alongside the oesophagus while the junction between the oesophagus and stomach remains in its usual position. Although some people remain symptom-free, larger paraoesophageal hernias may carry a higher risk of complications and require closer evaluation.

A hiatal hernia is not always discovered because of symptoms. It may also be identified during investigations such as a gastroscopy or imaging performed for other digestive concerns.

Why can a hiatal hernia cause persistent acid reflux?

The lower oesophageal sphincter (LOS) is a ring of muscle that helps prevent stomach contents from flowing backwards into the oesophagus. The diaphragm also supports this natural barrier.

A hiatal hernia can interfere with how these structures work together, making it easier for stomach acid to reflux into the oesophagus. However, a hiatal hernia is only one possible cause of persistent acid reflux. The frequency and severity of symptoms vary from person to person.

Several factors may influence whether a hiatal hernia contributes to ongoing reflux.

Changes to the anti-reflux barrier

When part of the stomach moves above the diaphragm, the lower oesophageal sphincter may not function as effectively. This can increase the likelihood of acid flowing back into the oesophagus, particularly after meals or when lying down.

The size of the hernia

Small hiatal hernias often cause few or no symptoms. Larger hernias are generally more likely to affect the normal function of the oesophagus and stomach, although symptom severity does not always correspond to the size of the hernia.

Other contributing factors

A hiatal hernia does not always explain persistent reflux on its own. Other factors, including excess body weight, dietary habits, delayed stomach emptying, smoking, and certain medications, may also contribute to ongoing symptoms. A medical assessment helps determine whether one or more factors are involved.

What symptoms can a hiatal hernia cause?

Many people with a hiatal hernia experience no symptoms.

When symptoms occur, they are commonly related to acid reflux and may include:

  • Frequent heartburn
  • Acid regurgitation or a sour taste in the mouth
  • Chest discomfort after eating
  • Difficulty swallowing
  • A feeling of fullness shortly after meals
  • Frequent burping or bloating
  • Chronic cough, throat irritation or hoarseness associated with reflux

These symptoms can also occur with other digestive conditions. Because chest discomfort may have causes unrelated to the digestive system, persistent or severe chest pain should always be medically assessed.

How is a hiatal hernia assessed?

If your symptoms suggest that a hiatal hernia or another digestive condition may be contributing to persistent reflux, your doctor will first review your symptoms, medical history and previous treatments.

Depending on your individual situation, further investigations may be recommended.

Gastroscopy

A gastroscopy allows the doctor to examine the oesophagus, stomach and upper part of the small intestine using a flexible camera. It can help identify a hiatal hernia, inflammation caused by acid reflux, or other conditions that may produce similar symptoms.

Imaging studies

In some cases, imaging such as a barium swallow may provide additional information about the size and position of the hernia and how the oesophagus functions during swallowing.

Additional oesophageal testing

Selected patients with persistent reflux or before considering surgery may require specialised tests, such as oesophageal manometry or pH monitoring, to better understand oesophageal function and acid exposure.

The most appropriate investigations depend on your symptoms and clinical assessment rather than the presence of reflux alone.

What are the available management options?

Treatment depends on whether the hiatal hernia is causing symptoms, the severity of reflux, and whether complications are present.

Lifestyle measures

For mild symptoms, your doctor may recommend measures such as:

  • Eating smaller meals
  • Avoiding lying down soon after eating
  • Maintaining a healthy weight where appropriate
  • Identifying foods that worsen reflux
  • Elevating the head of the bed if symptoms occur at night

These measures may help reduce reflux episodes but may not eliminate symptoms in every individual.

Medication

Acid-suppressing medications may be recommended to reduce stomach acid, relieve symptoms and allow inflammation of the oesophagus to heal. Medication helps control acid but does not repair the hernia itself.

Surgical treatment

Surgery is not required for every hiatal hernia. However, it may be considered for selected patients with persistent symptoms despite appropriate medical management, larger hiatal hernias, or complications related to the hernia.

The decision to proceed with surgery depends on factors such as your symptoms, overall health, investigation findings and treatment goals. Your surgeon will discuss whether surgery is appropriate based on your individual circumstances.

When should you seek medical advice?

Occasional acid reflux is common, but persistent symptoms should not be ignored.

Medical assessment may be appropriate if you experience:

  • Frequent or worsening heartburn
  • Symptoms that continue despite lifestyle measures or medication
  • Difficulty or pain when swallowing
  • Unexplained weight loss
  • Vomiting blood or passing black stools
  • Persistent chest discomfort after other urgent causes have been excluded

An assessment can help determine whether a hiatal hernia, GERD or another digestive condition is contributing to your symptoms and whether further investigations are appropriate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does every hiatal hernia cause acid reflux?

No. Many hiatal hernias do not cause symptoms. However, some can contribute to acid reflux by affecting the normal function of the lower oesophageal sphincter.

Can a hiatal hernia go away on its own?

A hiatal hernia usually does not resolve by itself. Management focuses on controlling symptoms and addressing any complications if they occur.

Does a hiatal hernia always require surgery?

No. Many hiatal hernias can be managed without surgery. Surgical treatment may be considered for selected patients after a comprehensive assessment.

Understanding persistent acid reflux and hiatal hernias

A hiatal hernia is one of several conditions that can contribute to persistent acid reflux, but not everyone with a hiatal hernia develops symptoms or requires surgical treatment. Understanding the underlying cause of ongoing reflux is important in determining the most appropriate management approach.

If you continue to experience persistent acid reflux or have symptoms that affect your daily life, the doctors at Clinic for Digestive Surgery can assess your symptoms, review your medical history, and recommend appropriate investigations where necessary. Based on the findings, they will discuss the available management options that are suitable for your individual condition.